Who Checks the Code When AI Writes It? Our Review Process
Every piece of AI-generated code goes through four checks before it is released: confirming that it meets the agreed requirements, reviewing the code manually, running automated tests, and getting final human approval. This human-in-the-loop approach ensures that people remain involved in maintaining the quality and security of AI-generated code. While AI can generate code, suggest improvements, and identify potential bugs, it cannot guarantee that the final product will work as expected. Human review, decision-making, and testing are essential before any AI-generated code is introduced into production.
At Velocity, we use AI to speed up AI MVP development, and our engineers review and validate every release. AI shortens the time it takes to get software into operation; engineers provide the oversight that keeps it reliable and maintainable.
![]()
What Is Human-in-the-Loop (HITL) AI?
Human-in-the-loop (HITL) AI is a method where people review, guide or approve work done by an AI system.
In software development, engineers check AI-generated code against technical requirements, security, and the app’s intended features before it’s merged into the codebase.
In a way, AI can be a programmer's assistant, creating login functionality for a customer, for instance. Even if the code seems to work, an engineer must still check that one user can’t access another user’s data, and what happens when a login fails.
Our AI Code Review Process: Four Checks Before Anything Goes Live
1. Define Requirements and Architecture
This includes the business needs, user roles, integrations, data handling, and technical constraints.
If you're building an e-commerce returns site, for instance, the group ought to figure out who can grant refunds and how the returns impact your stock, as well as how each system exchanges information about orders.
2. Developer Code Review
The review should be used to decide whether or not the code:
- Delivers the agreed business logic and requirements
- Uses the appropriate coding and architecture
- Deals with errors and unanticipated input appropriately
- Adds unwanted or dangerous dependencies or risks
- Can be comprehended and sustained by other developers
Other specialist reviews may also be required based on the context of the change for changes relating to sensitive information, payments, and authentication.
3. Automated Testing and Security Scans
These include unit tests, integration tests, static code analysis, dependency checks and security scans, which matter even more on older stacks see is your PHP software secure? Simply failing the automated tests does not necessarily mean that all the requirements are not met.
Tests can miss critical edge cases, especially when they are created with the same faulty assumptions as the actual code.
4. Final Human Validation and Approval
Depending on the project, this could include technical acceptance and security clearance, user acceptance testing, and sign-off to deploy.
Who is responsible for code generated by AI?
Well-governed human-in-the-loop AI systems have clearly defined human oversight rather than full automation.
- The software developer must review the code generated, fix any bugs, and ensure that the code meets the technical specifications set forth in the agreement.
- The technical leads or peer reviewers check the code quality, architecture, maintainability, and the possibility of integrating into the bigger app.
- Security experts review the changes to any sensitive data, authentication, payment processing, or any other function that might affect security, as necessary.
- When finished, The QA team confirms the feature works as intended.
- The software has been tested by the client or product owner. For instance, a finished feature may be considered as a method to investigate if it addresses the issue provided at the planning stage.
- Client acceptance (technical approval) may vary. You can determine if it's right for your business, but it still needs to be reviewed technically to see how the feature will be put to use.
What Should You Ask to See During Development?
If your product is built with AI, you can ask to see the review evidence. Agree access and reporting before development starts. It is advisable to work out the access and reporting arrangements beforehand in the development process.
Code Change and Review History
If your agreement includes access, you can view pull requests, review comments and approvals.
Testing Results
For instance, if you want to approve a customer registration feature, you want to run some tests to make sure it works, such as tests for customer registration success, invalid customer registration, and duplicate customer registration.
Working Demonstrations
You can run a staging version of your application, test some requests, and discuss with the development team about user journeys.
Release Readiness and Outstanding Issues
Knowing which defects remain prior to launch, the severity of the defects, and if there is an impact on critical operations is important.
Features completed, any known limitations, any remaining risks, and appropriate approvals are all features that could be included in a summary.
How Does Human-in-the-Loop Improve AI Accuracy?
The example below would be one such instance:
It is possible for an engineer to review the business logic and fix it.
The example below would be one such instance of human-in-the-loop increasing the accuracy of AI-generated answers. Users can add further business context, business judgment, and requirements that are not in the AI response.
But with humans involved, software is not guaranteed to be 100% correct. Independent checks, sensible testing, and accountability are important, as there is a risk of errors by reviewers.
What about the role of Humans in the Loop of AI Agents?
The risk is greater if an agent has the ability to change a system's configuration or take actions without additional permission.
For instance, an AI coding agent may spot a broken test and suggest the modification of the application. Without controls, it could also deploy and approve its own changes. Before important changes are merged or pushed to production, a human should approve them, just as a good AI assistant knows when to hand off to a human.
Let's consider some of the actual examples of humans in the loop of AI projects and how AI is assisting humans to make some of these important decisions.
What to Ask for an AI Development Partner?
At Velocity AI, we believe that AI-written code should be reviewed by humans, built on engineered AI workflows, and tested throughout the development process.
As part of your consideration of an AI-first development partner, you should decide who will review the code created by AI, how changes will be made for security issues, what documentation you'll be able to access, and who will be responsible for approving the final product.
AI can write code. The team that ships it is responsible for it
Want AI speed with human accountability? Talk to Velocity about your next build.